Видео

Hot take; I prefer initiatives and “chapters” over events

Benny is not that hard. It’s laid out in the back of the books and the FoX is a year long chapter of krakoa. Not everything will be explained in other titles.

I sorta agree with Benny and I have been readijg most of Fall of X but ALOT of the related books were pretty pointless honestly

Hearing him say, “homeboy” couldn’t be more unnatural

God Bennys laugh! Please just stop, dude theres areason your other channels never got as big as Comicstorian stick to what youre doing with the audio dramas stay away from discussions

While I'm not even going to attempt to argue the semantics of it all I agree with Benny's sentiments and disagree with Sal's lol.

Totally in favor of comicstorian, this event is a mess, just like the event before this.

Here's what I'm reading for Fall of X: finishing up Red and Immortal, Forever, Fall, Rise, then X-men #35. Everything else is just skippable to me, including pretty much all of Duggan's X-Men after #12.

Solaris? From all star Superman?

I completely agree with Sal that this is a status quo change

14:00 comedy gold

It’s an initiative.

Dawn of X, Reign of X, Destiny of X, and Fall of X are all initiatives as part of the Krakoa era with different status quos and Fall of X is merely the end point of it all. I disagree with Ben here, I think it's mostly because you haven't been reading it but i don't think this should've been made into full event. I recommend the british trio (X-men: Red, Immortal X-men, Legion of X).

That's NOT Henry Cavill?

It's only fatigue when you don't do it right.

Benny you should create your own Fall of x (potential, the whole X Series) on Comic Experiment!!

It's exactly like Dawn of X just pick the titles you like and read them and well thats that, I guess the marketing is bad and the story since Hickman left is whatever but I agree it's not an event

This video should be titled Sal gets annoyed with Benny 😂 It was funny to see them go back and forth

They should have cancelled all the x-books, and done Fall Of X, a 12 part series, like House/Powers that wrapped up everything. I expect they didn’t because they wanted the sales, but ironically I would have bought 12 fall of x issues, as it is I’ve bought nothing.

I definitely recommend reading the 1st issue of Dead X-Men! It actually is a crucial part of the Fall story, some really cool stuff happens & you get to see timelines that we missed out in due to the Fall coming earlier than expected. But ya, after that 1st issue they somehow made Dead X-Men obsolete and gave you no reason to keep reading unless you just wanted to go along for the ride. Everything after issue 1 is absolutely skippable.

Benny is an awful listener

I feel like Rob should be involved in this one 😂😂😂

I'm just reading Rise and X-Men Forever. That's all I can recommend.

Yeah NGL Marvel is losing it with these 40 parts x-overs. Has there ever been an event this stupidly stuffed full of issues that actually worked? I know my DC stuff has Absolute Power coming soon and I’m not sure how much that’s going to fall out into everyone’s series or not nor how many damn tie in specials it will have. Is DC Infinite and its reading library still a thing? I mainly read DC anyway and would rather pay one low price a month and save some hard copies for the indie books that I find interesting

Abit too much tie in for me

I haaaaaatttee the word woke...and I've barely heard many situations where the sentiment of that word even applies....but making Silver Surfer a female just because on a flimsy...reason. A gender swap changes the whole persona of the character and you're effectively writing a new character that nobody is familiar with. Maybe all the proper details aren't in place yet but this sounds....troubling. This feels like the same decisions that made people fall out with Phase 4. And that not even the most alarming thing. They couldn’t figure out how to introduce them so they are leaning into the multiverse yet again.

I like how everyone agrees Benny is the problem here not Fall of X lol. Fall of X isn’t an event it’s a status quo, just like how Dawn of DC isn’t an event. That would be like trying to follow a main plot through all DC books even though they are telling their own stories. Benny just has got to stop ranting about fall of x. Dudes making it seem like it’s impossible to read

What I've learned is the difference between an event and an initiative is that an event has the numbering on the cover and an initiative you just have to figure out the order on your own

I’m hoping that everyone genuinely enjoys this film. I want Marvel to win and take a huge boo boo on every. Single. Edgy. MCU hater!!

You guys need Dave from comic Herald LOL he will give you the perfect reading order and also share his disappointment in the fall of x

Am I crazy or does benny now just want to do a manga podcast but sal just aint having it cause his arguments always come back to manga which have absolutely nothing in common with western comics other than illustrations in a panel lay out.

I really feel for you Benny, i’ve been collecting the trades to the whole thing over the last three or four years i’m two weeks away from getting inferno and have been buying the Dawn of X compilations on my way there i just ordered Reign of X 11&12 and next week i’m getting the last two 13&14 before getting inferno and Batman Contagion (to finish my Batman no mans land run up) and so i’m still buying the trades in pairs starting Trials of X up to 10 the fallowing week they only printed Trials up to 12 out of 14 in english or it flips to Destiny of X but we’re not getting english prints. From there i have to buy the individual trades add in captain marvel and invincible iron man (a few volumes but i think i’m just going to get the whole runns if i like them i mean for iron man it seems to be the first three volumes but C.M. Is volumes 9-10) still don’t know how many of each series it will take to get to Fall of X Rise of X but the last Two Trials books have overlap with the ones you’d need anyway so i’m just stopping those at vol 10. Then i have to get X lives of wolverine, Sins of Sinister, Dark Web, A.X.E. Judgment day, and Devils Reign at least the X-men tie in book maybe Empyer as well and then figure out wich order to put them on the shelf in. TLDR: I’m with you Benny 👍

I was half way through this and realized it came out a year ago, thanks RUclips.

Feels like a story line affecting a large group of characters rather then an event which usually involves a smaller group of key players and then it affects others as well, reminds me of Blackest Night of here’s the leaders of the corps but here’s tie ins of how the emotionally connected dead risen and the whole world deals with that. Probably would be best with a number system of parts then here’s other parts of the world dealing with the happening

"Dont worry about that" "Dont worry about that" "Dont worry about that" x repeat 100 Ha this was so funny and so confusing at the same time

I don't like it when my two dads fight.

I’m speaking from a place of love, but ngl it’s hard to hear Benny continually talk out of his ass about everything

Benny: "So what happens in Dead X-Men?" Sal: "I'm sorry do you actually think I'm going to explain a story plot succinctly? You must be new here!" 😂

I'm with Sal on this whole thing but if you like a specific x Men writer then read all of the books from that person. Duggen wrote Uncanny Avengers, Iron Man, Fall of House of X, and X-Men. So as a Duggen fan with what he's done with X-Men, those would be what I care about. Just pick and choose, it doesn't matter at the end since it's all going back to issue #1s this August.

Iron man still dont work in this story with me they wanted an avenger inside the xmen lore other then the axe event

I heard Xavier is evil now 😒

Imo benny comparing fall of X to my hero academia is wild The comparison just doesn’t work it’s mad how obsessed Benny is with always comparing the two

It is becoming increasingly fustrating watching Benny try to argue with Sal when he clearly has not read or not closely read the material they are discussing. I’m truly not trying to be rude, but it is very difficult to listen/watch a show when one host has to constantly correct the other about what is actually happening in the comic. One of the great things about Sal and Comic pop is that while he is giving great insight, he is also able to give important context about the character history and whats happening to the artists/ writers . While Benny on the other hand seems to not fully digest the material they are discussing.

Iron man jaeger suit is cool

It hard read x-men comic books now

Okay so usually I’d disagree with Benny on FoX but this concluding chapter, like the X-Men Forever/Rise&Fall/X-Men/Iron Man 5+ concurrent series is actually a massive pain in the ass to read. The actual status quo of post Hellfire Gala was nowhere as difficult as Benny was making it seem but right now he absolutely has a point. Cause Marvel is really cracking that whip and saying put 2 years worth of story into 6 months

Start making good movies again with new ip and people will show up. Hollywood has made terrible tent-pole films for the most part for last 15 years. The success of the MCU just masked the problem, when covid hit and they started releasing a steady stream of garbage it exposed how bad things actually were. I remember how i couldn't wait to see the trailers at the theater for upcoming summer blockbusters. Now that feeling has gone away, Hollywood did it to themselves.

I think James Gunn is teasing us a bit here. I think this shot is not even a in scene shot. Maybe he’s just in wardrobe casually putting on his suit. Maybe the scene he’s about to shoot calls for this particular suit. Maybe his suit has a zipper in the back to where it is down because he can’t put on his boots unless his suit is unfastened. Hence the looseness of the suit in the upper shoulder/neck region. Maybe Corenswet doesn’t even have a clue that this picture is going to be the photo for the suit reveal which explains the uninterested look on his face. Gunn: yeah let’s use this pic, put an energy blast behind him and watch the world go wild 😂🤣😂. Mission accomplished JG🔥🔥🔥. Can’t wait for this movie

The suit looks wrinkly, cheap, bland, baggy and like star lord's costume with an s on it. It doesn't look good at all.

Why do y'all make 2 videos just to pause 50 times in the reaction maybe I sound like a hater but I just don't get it